News Center

Elsewhere Online twitter Facebook SLS Blogs YouTube SLS Channel Linked In SLSNavigator SLS on Flickr

Online Libel Claims Abound

Publication Date: 
June 01, 2009
California Lawyer
June D. Bell

Professor Mark A. Lemley is quoted in the California Lawyer in a story about legal aspects of online defamation:

Welcome to the Web 2.0 world of user-generated content, where positive reviews can attract new customers—but negative reviews may inspire the subjects to head to court. One suit, waged by a chiropractor who was poorly reviewed on Yelp, settled in mediation earlier this year, and a second suit, filed last year by a pediatric dentist, is pending on appeal. A third case, also involving a dentist, settled last year after a superior court judge in San Francisco, where Yelp is based, granted the defendant's anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation) motion. California attorneys, meanwhile, say they're fielding an increasing number of calls from angry business owners seeking recourse.


In addition to being difficult to prove and win, allegations of online defamation can also backfire: A stray negative posting may fade into obscurity, but a lawsuit over it can provoke exactly the kind of negative publicity that business owners are desperate to avoid, notes Mark Lemley, who teaches Internet law at Stanford Law School and is a partner at Durie Tangri Lemley Roberts & Kent in San Francisco.