Citation

Publication Date: 2007-05-01
Format: Working Paper
Bibliography: Alvin K. Klevorick and Alan O. Sykes, United States Courts and the Optimal Deterrence of International Cartels: A Welfarist Perspective on Empagran, Stanford Law and Economics Olin Working Paper, No. 338 / Yale Law and Economics Research Paper, No. 340 (2007).

More

E. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. v. Empagran S.A. concerned a private antitrust suit for damages against a global vitamins cartel. The central issue in the litigation was whether foreign plaintiffs injured by the cartel's conduct abroad could bring suit in U.S. court, an issue that was ultimately resolved in the negative. We take a welfarist perspective on this issue and inquire whether optimal deterrence requires U.S. courts to take subject matter jurisdiction under U.S. law for claims such as those in Empagran. Our analysis considers, in particular, the arguments of various economist amici in favor of jurisdiction and arguments of the U.S. and foreign government amici against jurisdiction. We explain why the issue is difficult to resolve, and identify several economic concerns, which the amici did not address, that may counsel against jurisdiction. We also analyze the legal standard enunciated by the Supreme Court and applied on remand by the DC Circuit, and we argue that its focus on independent harms and proximate causation is problematic and does not provide an adequate economic foundation for resolving the underlying legal issues. A revised version of this paper is forthcoming in ANTITRUST STORIES from Foundation Press, edited by Daniel Crane and Eleanor Fox.

Other publications by this author

View All

• Corporate Liability for Extraterritorial Torts Under the Alien Tort Statute and Beyond: An Economic Analysis
  2012-12-31
• Efficient Breach of International Law: Optimal Remedies, "Legalized Noncompliance," and Related Issues
  2011-11-01
• A Preference for Development: The Law and Economics of GSP
  2011-08-15
• The Dispute Settlement Mechanism--Ensuring Compliance?
  2011-06-19
• "Optimal" Retaliation in the WTO
  2011-06-01
• International Trade and Domestic Regulation
  2011-01-02
• Public Versus Private Enforcement of International Economic Law: Standing and Remedy
  2010-11-01
• Economic Foundations of the Law of the Sea
  2010-10-19
• The Law, Economics and Politics of Preferential Trade Agreements and Discrimination in International Trade
  2010-08-31
• Currency "Manipulation' and World Trade
  2010-04-15