Citation

Publication Date: 2010-12-27
Format: Blog Postings
Bibliography: Barbara van Schewick, The FCC's Open Internet Rules -- Stronger than You Think, Internet Architecture and Innovation blog, December 27, 2010.

More

Since the FCC adopted rules to protect an open Internet on Tuesday, many have asked whether the rules could have gone further to better protect users and innovators or whether the FCC’s political strategy was flawed. These are all valid questions, and I’m sure they will continue to be debated for a long time. However, in this post, I want to focus on the protections for users and innovators that the FCC did adopt.

Since Julius Genachowski, the chairman of the FCC, circulated his proposal for network neutrality rules to the other commissioners on December 1, Commissioner Copps and Commissioner Clyburn, the two other Democratic commissioners, had been negotiating with the chairman over improvements to the order. Since the two Republican commissioners had made clear that they would not back any network neutrality proposal, a rejection by Copps (or Clyburn) would have killed the proposal.

When the FCC published the text of the order on Thursday afternoon, it became clear how important these negotiations have been. While Commissioners Copps and Clyburn did not get the exact protections for users and innovators they had asked for, they managed to improve the chairman’s original proposal quite a bit.

Other publications by this author

View All

• Public Interest Requires Public Input: Verizon/Android Tethering
  2011-06-30
• Network Neutrality: What a Non-Discrimination Rule Should Look Like
  2010-09-30
• Future of the Internet Symposium: Do We Need a New Generativity Principle?
  2010-09-08
• Future of the Internet Symposium: Generative End Hosts vs. Generative Networks?
  2010-09-08
• Google-Verizon Should Prompt FCC to Demand Net Neutrality
  2010-08-12
• Internet Architecture and Innovation
  2010-07-30
• Workshop on Approaches to Preserving the Open Internet
  2010-04-28
• Workshop on Innovation, Investment and the Open Internet
  2010-01-13
• Letter from Jack Balkin, John Blevins, Jim Chen, Larry Lessig, Barbara van Schewick, and Tim Wu, Professors of Law, to Julius Genachowski, Chairman, Federal Communications Commission
  2009-11-09
• Brief Amicus Curiae of Professors Jack M. Balkin, Jim Chen, Lawrence Lessig, Barbara van Schewick, and Timothy Wu Urging that the FCC's Order be Affirmed
  2009-10-09