Citation

Publication Date: 2011-08-12
Format: Blog Postings
Bibliography: Hank Greely, Thoughts on the Eleventh Circuit Health-Care Law Ruling, Scope Blog, August 12, 2011.

More

The great “Constitutionality of the Health Reform Bill” contest is now tied, one to one. Earlier this summer, the Sixth Circuit, which hears appeals from federal courts in Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee, ruled, in a two to one vote, that the bill is constitutional. Today, the Eleventh Circuit, which hears appeals from federal courts in Florida, Georgia, and Alabama, ruled, in another two to one vote, that it is unconstitutional.

The main message is that the Supreme Court is going to decide this issue. Before today, there was some chance that all the circuit courts would agree and the Supreme Court would not get involved; the circuit split created by the 11th Circuit decision makes that highly unlikely. It is not impossible – in either case the losing side can ask the entire court (not just the three judges on that particular panel) to rehear the appeal, taking it “en banc.” So the full Sixth or Eleventh Circuit (or both!) could overturn their panels. It seems more likely, though, that the full courts, expecting the Supreme Court ultimately to resolve the issue, will let these decisions speed up to the next level.

Other publications by this author

View All

• Foreword
  2012-04-24
• Direct Brain Interventions to "Treat" Disfavored Human Behaviors: Ethical and Social Issues
  2012-03-06
• Remembering the Sheep that Changed the World
  2012-02-28
• Designer Eggs and Stem Cell Sausage
  2012-02-16
• The Equality of Allocation by Lot
  2011-12-02
• Noninvasive Prenatal Diagnosis: Pregnant Women's Interest and Expected Uptake
  2011-10-26
• Reference Guide on Neuroscience
  2011-09-28
• Human/Nonhuman Chimeras: Assessing the Issues
  2011-09-19
• Law and the Biosciences
  2011-06-06
• The Future of Direct-to-Consumer Clinical Genetic Tests
  2011-06-01